C of Brisbane on Freedom for the stupid is important too
margaret barstow on Making prison(er)s work better
Ed on Beef up public access to FOI, expert says
Jacek on 'Black fellow' tag costs man his job
The wearing of bike helmets and car seat belts engages the classic liberty v public good argument. Bill Curnow, a CLA member, gives his opinion that there has been little evidence-based analysis of the public good. It's time for some independent and open inquiries, he says.
The Editor, The Age: Your editorial “It`s time to cut racism from the constitution” (20 Jan 2012) contains a very telling point when it asks us to consider what message would be sent to Aborigines and Torres Strait Islanders (and to the world) if they are not acknowledged as Australia`s first peoples and racially discriminatory measures in the constitution are not eradicated .
I see that persistent apologist Jim Unkles is pushing new Attorney-General Nicola Roxon to act on pardoning the Boer War multiple murderers Harry Morant and Peter Handcock. He is offering to "brief her – that is, present his version of the 1901 court martial – claiming a miscarriage of justice took place in 1901.
Terry Briscoe died in custody in Alice Springs early in 2012. Police say he fell and hit his head, soon after dying of cardiac arrest. People arrested with him allege police officers bashed him. CLA doesn't know which is correct, but we do know that both police and the NT justice system are on trial in this case. CLA believes interstate police should be called in to assist the coroner's investigation, rather than NT police investigating their own. Here is an open letter from the dead man's uncle to the Chief Minister of the NT.
...and NT Police Association chief Vince Kelly has penned an impassioned letter about Aborigines in the NT, in which he defends his police officers and asserts there was no bashing.
As Disability Commissioner Graeme Innes so clearly explains, “Imprisonment can do a grave injustice to the intellectually impaired” – SMH/The Age 29/12/2011– Prisons also fail to rehabilitate many other prisoners. With boredom so prevalent and prisons inadequately staffed with qualified people to undertake the difficult task of helping prisoners turn their lives around, it is no wonder that about 43% of prisoners return to prison within two years of release. Pre-release and post-release programs seem to be non-existent.
Being selected for a 'Census' activity can be like the reverse of winning the lottery: all pain and no gain. CLA often gets complaints about mandatory rules of the Australian Bureau of Statistics for their numerous types of surveys. Here Toni Walker wonders what are the odds of being picked twice in a decade? What do you think?
A man says he has been summarily dismissed, without a hearing, for describing a fellow worker as a 'black fellow'. Conflicting rights are always difficult to resolve - what do you think?
Why does our PM do something as stupid as putting the gay marriage issue to a conscience vote? We all know how she feels about the subject...and she’s up a tree.
The Editor, The Age: Community expectations of law and order can be sensibly met if Tamar Hopkin`s advice in her article 'Police searches need new profile' (8/11) is heeded. As is explained, racial profiling by police – stopping and searching individuals because of their race – is counter-productive as it leads to distrust of the police and feelings of alienation by those apprehended. Her call for the police to issue a receipt when they stop someone (as is done in Britain) is on the right track, that will compel them to show just cause for doing so, leading to a greater transparency of police procedures and so reducing any likelihood of unwarranted harassment by those charged to uphold the law and respect people`s rights.
– Keith McEwan, CLA member, Castlemaine, Victoria
Sometimes life in the raw rolls up to your feet, sits down and listens. Australia is a Lucky Country...but not for everyone, all the time. Keith McEwan reflects on people enjoying the liberty of free music in the sunshine...and of freedom dying before an ASIO assessment.
At 2.40pm I attended A1 Fruit and Vegetable market in Glenorchy ( a Hobart suburb) to buy vegetables as I often do. Today I was riding my motor scooter with another rider.
On arriving at A1 I noticed three cars in an accident, Hyundai Getz silver, a Suzuki Vitara maroon, and Ford Falcon silver. I spoke to the lady who owns the Suzuki to enquire if she was ok and she told me what happened. She said she was just out of the car when she heard the scream of the car and a bang, she was clearly upset and said that she wished she hadn’t come here now. I agreed and said it could have been much worse.
Editor, Koori Mail: A nation, like a person, should be true to itself, if it is to earn the respect of not being false in any way, at home or abroad. For Australians, this means frankly acknowledging the harmful, discriminatory treatment of the indigenous people since our formation as a nation to the present day.
The Editor, The Age: The article, 'No room for complacency on terrorism' (The Age, 8 Sept 2011) is timely as it reveals that, of the $10 billion Australia has spent on national security reforms since 2001, less than 1% has been allocated to countering the ideology that fuels religious extremism at home.
The Editor, The Age: Ombudsman George Brouwer`s report and your editorial on Victoria`s prisons ( The Age 31/8, 1/9) reveal that Victoria`s prisons are failing the community in the treatment of those incarcerated. Over the years an “out of sight, out of mind” policy has prevailed by those charged with protecting the community and rehabilitating offenders.
Responding to your report “Let jurors speak, says Lindy Chamberlain” by Subiaco Post (Perth) editor Brett Christian, 3 Sept 2011: I fully support Lindy Chamberlain Creighton’s call for jurors to be allowed to speak publicly and debate their verdicts. About 10 years ago jurors in WA were banned from disclosing discussions in the jury room. Lindy was promoting an international justice conference to be held in Perth on 8-10 March in 2012, organised by Justice WA.
Smoking today, alcohol tomorrow, food the day after? That's the anti-free will road we're heading down, says a smoker who tells his local MP that the only thing consistent about the government policy on cigarettes is its hypocrisy.
I am worried about personal choice. Citizens have the right to choose how
they live their own life. That should include what they like to eat! It is
extremely controlling of the government to interfere with one's choice of
foods – fast food, alcohol, cigarettes, beef in Indonesia, and now shark
fins!! Let's tell the government to mind their own business.
It's similar with the carbon tax. The GST was a tax, but at least citizens
had a choice to buy less processed foods at the supermarket and stick to
fresh produce that does not incur GST. This carbon tax will in effect make
all utilities more expensive for everyone and these are NECESSITIES of life!
It's time to make a stand on individual freedom to choose.
– Chen Ching Man, Watson ACT
Editor, West Australian: The Prime Minister is obliged to support a Presidential clemency for Andrew Chan, an Australian citizen, in Indonesia. In doing so, she is supporting the UN Human Rights Charter which advocates all nations abolish capital punishment, which Australia has done.
While not always agreeing with Brian Tennant's stance, I did some numbers on the payout and I think Daryl Beamish has been most inadequately "compensated?". Calculating this payout, at a conservative interest rate, should he have been "paid" on a yearly basis, means his first years "compensation" was but $1205.00. I earnt $2300 that same year. That doesn't even enter into "compensation" for wrongful imprisonment.
Perhaps the names of those responsible need to be be researched and PUBLISHED. They were the real criminals. Keep up the pressure.
Keith Jenner, Perth
Editor, Canberra Times: Julia Gillard and Tony Abbott have both shed crocodile tears over the death of yet another Aussie soldier in Afghanistan. When asked about the validity of them being in Afghanistan at all, their response was: ‘We must let things run their course.’ What course? Our soldiers aren’t wanted there. The Afghans have given them and their Yankee mates the thumbs down, ‘Get out. We’ll take care of ourselves.’ But the Aussies and the Yanks are quite happy to stay and let their men be killed. And so, it seems are our PM and the Leader of the Opposition.
– Marie Gordon, CLA member, Palmerston ACT
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | © Civil Liberties Australia A04043 - ABN 46 368 619 567 |